Can We Create Architecture That Embraces the Sacred and the Secular? – Common Edge
9 mins read

Can We Create Architecture That Embraces the Sacred and the Secular? – Common Edge

A modern Prevalent Edge report by Duo Dickinson regarded as sacred architecture in an increasingly secular time. Portion of the short article was dependent on a research by the Pew Exploration Middle, which has for years probed Us residents about their frequency of church attendance together with developments in religious beliefs. Youve likely by now read that issues have not been looking superior for arranged faith and worship in the U.S. above the earlier number of a long time. According to Gallup, the proportion of U.S. older people in 2020 who belong to an structured religion fell to 47, down 23 details considering the fact that the convert of the 21st century, the first time it dipped to fewer than half of the populace in the 80 a long time the group has tracked membership. The drop has a generational angle: the young you are, the a lot less likely youre a congregation member (58% for Little one Boomers, 36% for Millennials).

The news is not excellent if youre a clergy member and may be troubling for architects who have constructed techniques on the design and style of standard spiritual properties. As somebody who has studied and published and lectured thoroughly about spiritual architecture over various a long time, however, its interesting to notice what is at this time happening to spiritual architecture. Its adapting in nontraditional means, as Ive written on Typical Edge in advance of. I believe that that whats happening to religious architecture has tiny to do with secularism. Following all, Pew has also uncovered that 70% of U.S. older people explain by themselves as religious in some wayhardly a secular wave.

Whats heading on?

In a latest write-up in The Atlantic, Why People Instantly Stopped Hanging Out, Derek Thompson notes that in the previous couple many years social teams in the U.S. have been in constant drop. He cites sociologist Robert Putnams seminal 2000 book, Bowling On your own, which seemed at the evaporation of membership in social golf equipment, organizations, mutual-gain societies, bowling leaguesand religious congregations. People in america now expend far more time alone than ever right before in U.S. background, Thompson writes, while rates of nervousness and melancholy rise. Also increasing exponentially, of course, is the sum of time we gaze into screens. In accordance to annual data in the American Time Use Study, no make a difference what your gender, age, ethnicity, profits, or instruction, genuine-earth socializing has declined. That consists of attending spiritual solutions.

“…the really coronary heart of the decline of peoples engagement with organized religion: facial area-to-deal with rituals and customs are in retreat, in each secular and sacred options.


Thompson argues that extra time with our screens indicates less time currently being active with community corporations, youth athletics, or socializing with coworkers (primarily with additional hybrid and distant work solutions for numerous), or actively attending church each individual technology attends less than their moms and dads did. Individuals are suffering a type of ritual recession, writes Thompson, finding to the extremely coronary heart of the decline of peoples engagement with structured faith: face-to-facial area rituals and customs are in retreat, in both equally secular and sacred settings.

Regarding peoples religious beliefs or spirituality, or the dwindling attendance in sacred buildings, Im not positive we can point the finger at a rise of secularism. A increasing amount of persons explain by themselves as non secular but not religious (SBNR), a preference that we may well characterize as opting out of shared deal with-to-experience rituals and customs. Youthful older people (aged 18-49) account for almost 60% of the SBNR crowd.

The Pew study, Spirituality Among the Individuals, offers us a new check out into American beliefs, which previous scientific studies did not, as they targeted primarily on the drop of Individuals attending religious companies. In the new review, 70% of People in america describe on their own as spiritual, or agree that spirituality is vital to their life of this group, 22% detect as SBNR, which leaves about 48% as non secular and spiritual. Couple SBNR people (2%) go to arranged religious expert services. On the other hand, about 50 percent of them say they are affiliated with a faith but dont worship in a team environment. Spirituality takes a lot of varieties. Individuals who experience connected to one thing more substantial than themselvesnature, the universe, beautyare most well known being related to God or being related to my real self, significantly fewer so. Low on the record of essentials to being religious is remaining related with other persons and continuing spouse and children traditions. The diminished value of these two suggests that modern day spirituality is far a lot less social. Any shock that spiritual structures are emptying?

The survey identified that a great chunk of the respondents have interaction in spiritual practices at the very least at the time a thirty day period in buy to truly feel linked with their legitimate self, with one thing larger than themselves, or with other people today. Forty-4 per cent of U.S. grown ups report that they routinely dedicate portion of their working day hunting inward or centering by themselves. Far more than a quarter shell out time in mother nature. About 22% meditate, 7% exercise, and 4% follow yoga. All of these religious techniques strike me as principally solitary pursuitsagain, no need for sacred buildings in this article.

If the have to have for space designed for ritualwhat could possibly be referred to as sacred spaceis in decrease, what comes upcoming? The critical may possibly be found in the dichotomy of sacred versus secular. I would argue that for numerous men and women today its a fake separation, probably 1 thats fading. The idea of the sacred as current in the secular is not unheard of in several religions all-around the globe, which could see the divine in character, or in shrines and altars identified in residences. For case in point, users of todays Amish faith in the U.S. dont create church buildings they dont have sacred structures. Alternatively, they acquire for worship in smaller groups in their homes, just like early Christians did prior to the first goal-crafted church buildings appeared in the 3rd century CE. The orientation of contemporary individuals who explain by themselves as non secular but not religious suits this sample.

Edward Anders Sviks Lutheran Church of the Fantastic Shepherd, Bloomington, MN, 1967, did not glance like a church.


A midcentury contemporary American church architect who was highly suspect of buildings as sacred objects was Edward Anders Svik, who practiced largely in the Midwest. Svik examined architecture at Yale shortly just after Environment War II, but prior to that he was a college student of Christian theology. He produced some pretty radical strategies about religious structures. Svik thought that the division involving sacred and secular structures was a pagan thought: Spirituality shouldnt focus on sacred architecture but on people today, on steps somewhat than things. He argued that religious architecture must be thoroughly secular in character. This sort of buildings shouldnt be developed completely for worship, but versatile sufficient to accommodate a amount of makes use of, for social, recreational, and even athletic activities and for this sort of matters as working day-care facilities, clinics, and housing for the elderly. As I have talked with a wide range of architecture students above the past several decades about sacred area, this is the way they see the entire world, that there are only sacred acts: expressions of kindness, compassion, caring for other individuals, generosity, volunteering.

Nowadays, nonprofit corporations, this sort of as Partners for Sacred Places, primarily based in Philadelphia, assist dwindling congregations that have large, practically empty spiritual properties come across nonprofit partners that may possibly use aspect of the congregations areas for the arts, clinics, housing, soup kitchens, education and learning, and neighborhood facilities. The notion is to make far better use of present spiritual buildings that might provide their communities, just like Svik envisioned additional than a half-century back.

Appears like a pretty sacred undertaking to me.

Showcased picture: Westwood Lutheran Church restoration by Kodet Architectural Team, Ltd., St. Louis Park, MN, intended by Edward Anders Svik in 1963. Dana Wheelock Images, courtesy of Kodet.